Online dating can feel like a maze of frustration for many people. Being rejected on Tinder is a common experience, where some users find love quickly while others feel like they’re shouting into a void, which can be damaging for someone’s confidence. For countless men, that void takes the form of Tinder. It’s a place where effort piles up and results remain painfully low. Hayden’s story captures that reality.
Over five years, Hayden swiped right more than 2 million times. Despite this massive effort, he was rejected on Tinder by nearly every woman. He matched with only 2,053 people, started 1,269 conversations, and landed just one date. That date didn’t go well.
At first, many users sympathized with Hayden. They blamed Tinder and claimed average men didn’t stand a chance. But once his profile circulated online, public opinion shifted. People realized his failure had less to do with Tinder and unfortunately more to do with how he presented himself.
A Walking Red Flag in Profile Form
When Hayden’s Tinder profile appeared online, the reason for all the rejections became obvious. He didn’t just get ignored; he built a profile that turned people off instantly.
He posted three images of himself holding a fish, a tired cliché that many women actively avoid. Then, thought to include the fact that he owns 33 snakes and enjoys vacations spent catching more snakes. One photo showed him in a hoodie that said “SITYA ass on my face,” with a silhouette of a naked woman. He even refused to disclose his vaccination status.
All of this created a strong negative impression for Hayden. Rather than seem confident or unique, Hayden came across as crude and unaware. Women didn’t miss out on a nice guy; they saw clear red flags and chose to swipe left, adding to Hayden’s feelings of being rejected on Tinder.
A Quick Blast from the Past
If you’re a Millennial, you might remember the early 2000s website Hot or Not. It debuted in 2000 as a simple photo-rating site called Am I Hot or Not, where users uploaded pictures and strangers rated them from 1 to 10, sometimes amassing millions of visits per day within weeks. Although it started as a novelty, it quickly evolved and in 2001 launched a matchmaking feature called “Meet Me,” which allowed users to connect based on their mutual ratings.
In many ways, Hot or Not played the role of Tinder’s grandfather. It gamified attractiveness and turned rating into a social experience long before swipes and matches became mainstream.
Of course, Hot or Not wasn’t the first online dating platform ever. That credit goes to Match.com, which launched way back in 1995. It took a more traditional, profile-based approach to connecting people, and it’s still around today.
As for Hot or Not, the site was bought in 2012 by the founder of Badoo, rebranded as Chat & Date, and rolled into the Badoo network. These days, it functions a lot like modern dating apps, matching users and allowing them to communicate with each other over chat.
So if you ever feel like Tinder is overwhelming, just remember, the idea of rating people online started over two decades ago, and we’ve been spiraling ever since.
All in all, if Tinder made you feel like your profile photo was a judgment day event, remember that Hot or Not did that long before. And Chat & Date and Match.com show how that original concept grew into today’s swiping culture.
Low Effort, High Expectations
Hayden’s experience reflects a common issue among men using dating apps. Many post low-effort profiles, write nothing in their bios, or add jokes that come off as offensive. Despite that, they expect women to engage and respond with interest.
When women don’t match, these men often lash out and blame them. They call women picky or say dating apps are rigged, but Hayden had over 1,200 conversations and still failed to make a single real connection. That pattern doesn’t point to unfair treatment. It points to poor communication and a lack of effort.
Instead of blaming others, these men need to look inward. If you keep getting rejected on Tinder, your approach likely needs serious improvement. It might not hurt to ask a female friend or family member for some advice.
Women Are Not Too Picky
Today’s women have raised their standards, and rightly so. According to a recent Happn survey, 90% of Gen Z daters want a partner who shares the same political views, personal values, and sexual compatibility before meeting in person. Some might call this pickiness, others might call it practicality.
A 2023 Pew study revealed that 63% of men aged 18 to 29 are single, compared to only 34% of women. Women are choosing to stay single rather than settle for relationships that lack compatibility or respect.
An internal OkCupid analysis also showed that women rated 80% of men as “below average” when it comes there their physical appearance. These numbers don’t mean women are impossible to please. Instead, they show that many men aren’t meeting even the basic standards that women expect in a partner. When men ignore these expectations, they end up being rejected on apps like Tinder.
Movements Like 4B Reflect the Shift
Hayden’s story also explains why many women are turning to the 4B movement. This community encourages women to focus on personal growth and step away from relationships that drain or disrespect them.
The movement isn’t rooted in hate. Women who join 4B are not swearing off love, they are choosing not to waste energy on people who refuse to treat them with respect.
Hayden’s experience makes the 4B mindset look entirely reasonable. After all, when men put minimal effort into dating and still expect rewards, women have every right to ignore them.
Bad Advice from Toxic Influencers
Another major reason men struggle on dating apps is the influence of toxic online personalities. The manosphere, filled with influencers and so-called dating coaches, can feed men harmful ideas.
They claim that looks don’t matter if you “dominate her mind.” Then they argue that women only want rich partners. Finally, they insist that society works against men.
These influencers profit from male frustration. Their goal isn’t to help men build healthy relationships. Instead, they want to keep followers angry and dependent on their content. A man in a stable relationship doesn’t need their advice or buy their courses.
Unfortunately, men who follow this guidance often become more isolated and bitter. They listen to people who have never built healthy relationships themselves. As a result, they remain stuck and continue getting rejected on Tinder.
What Hayden’s Story Teaches Us
Hayden’s story doesn’t expose flaws in Tinder or suggest that women have unreasonable standards. It highlights the consequences of poor self-awareness and a lack of effort.
Swiping millions of times without success proves that quantity can’t replace quality. True success in dating begins with self-reflection. A thoughtful profile, respectful attitude, and genuine interest in connection go a long way.
So if you’re ignored on dating apps, stop blaming others. Ask yourself, “what can I do better?” Then do it. Growth won’t guarantee a match overnight, but it gives you a much better shot than entitlement ever will.
Read More: Why There’s a Growing Trend of Straight Men Dating Trans Women