Myra Hindley’s name still elicits strong repulsion in Britain today, cementing her reputation as one of the most notorious female killers in modern history. Her heinous collaboration with Ian Brady resulted in the infamous Moors Murders, a horrific series of child abductions, sexual assaults, and murders that terrorized Manchester and the isolated Saddleworth Moor from July 1963 to October 1965.
The nature of the crimes, which included the premeditated targeting of vulnerable young children aged 10 to 17, as well as the methodical burial of their remains on desolate moorland, shocked the British public conscience and the world to its core. Hindley’s active and willing participation, motivated by a perverse devotion to Brady, completely defied the stereotype of a female criminal, cementing her reputation as a figure of pure evil.
The subsequent trials and widespread media coverage not only revealed the couple’s heinous crimes but also had a significant and long-lasting impact on British criminal law. The case contributed to growing public pressure, which eventually resulted in the abolition of the death penalty in the UK. Furthermore, the sensationalist nature of the coverage fundamentally changed how the media covered serial killers, sparking debates about ethics, victim privacy, and the possibility of “trial by media.”
Despite spending decades in prison, Hindley was never free of public condemnation. Her repeated, often highly publicized parole applications were consistently denied, highlighting the deep and long-lasting trauma inflicted on the nation and cementing her status as a symbol of unforgivable crime until her death in 2002.
Early Life and Formative Years
Myra Hindley was born on 23 July 1942 in Crumpsall, a working‑class suburb of Manchester. Her father, Bob Hindley, served in the Parachute Regiment during World War II. He spent most of her first 3 years away in North Africa. Her mother, Nellie, depended heavily on her own mother, who moved in with them to help raise the child.
Myra Hindley’s father, Bob Hindley, significantly influenced her turbulent early home life when he returned and began doing menial jobs for work. The family lived together in a two‑up, two‑down house on Eaton Street, Gorton. Bob’s issues with alcohol and violence were severe; his drinking aggravated his temper, resulting in frequent beatings of his wife, Nellie. Myra later described her grandmother’s intervention in these altercations, emphasizing the chronic domestic chaos that characterized her upbringing.
Family Dynamics and Street Violence
When Myra was 4, her younger sister, Maureen, was born. It is presumed that her parents, struggling to manage the household with 2 young children, briefly sent Myra to live with her grandmother. While Myra’s absence was a temporary arrangement, Myra never returned to her parents’ home afterward.
In her autobiographical accounts, she blamed her father for shaping her personality, emphasizing how her ‘tough’ upbringing and violent father drove her to become the monster she’s known as today. Her father encouraged her to fight, teaching her how to defend herself against boys her own age and forcing her to confront her bullies. When she won a street fight, he gave her attention and approval. She also built a reputation as a ‘street fighter’ among her peers.
That same reputation helped her defend Maureen and her friends. Pauline Reed, one of those friends, escaped an attack by another lad. Pauline Reed became the first victim of the Moors Murderer ten years later. Myra had once sheltered her; later, she drew her into the vehicle headed for the moors.
Appearance, Personality, and Lack of Empathy
Myra was seen as a sensible, capable, and well-liked babysitter by her school friends. Neighbors found her agreeable, and parents trusted her with their children. While academically mediocre at 13, she displayed responsibility around adults. However, her tomboyish nature caused her to clash with peers who considered her unattractive.
Despite being nicknamed “Square Arse” by her peers for her physical appearance, Myra Hindley’s early life was more conventional. She participated in Catholic communion classes and found solace in reading, enjoying the works of authors like Beatrix Potter and Enid Blyton. According to her friend Susan Carter, these books provided an escape from what she described as Hindley’s “average working-class childhood.”
Early Fascination With Death
From an early age, Myra exhibited unsettling and bizarre reactions towards death and the macabre. When classmates hurt themselves, Myra rarely showed distress. She did not empathize with others’ pain. However, at age 15, her best friend, Michael Higgins, drowned, and she was devastated. Myra felt intense guilt over Michael’s death, as they frequently swam together. Tragically, she had not joined him on the day he died.
According to Myra’s accounts, her macabre fascination began with Michael’s death. When they laid out Michael’s body, Myra exhibited an unusual fascination with it instead of showing sadness or distress. His mother took the rosary from his hand and handed it to her. Myra soon quit school, converted to Roman Catholicism, and began fixating on images that others would find repulsive. She recorded recollections in her journals of a decapitated dog on the railway line, a cat torn in two by dogs, and a boy bleeding to death after a lorry accident.
Meeting Ian Brady and the Descent Into Violence
Myra Hindley first met Ian Brady at Manchester’s chemical firm Millwards. She began her career as a shorthand typist in January 1961, at the age of 19. Brady, a stock clerk, was taller than average, well-dressed, and unusually serious for his position. Myra later highlighted in her diary how smitten she was with him from their first introduction. Brady’s reserved, professional, and aloof demeanor piqued Myra’s interest while also confusing her, as she was used to men or boys saying that they liked her.
Brady’s influence led her to break off her engagement to a local boy. She found his austere intellect and ability to read Mein Kampf in German romantic, telling friends he was the first man she knew who could do so. However, his explosive fits of anger, like shouting at bookmakers over lost bets, were reminiscent of her father’s own rage.
Relationship as a Replacement for Her Past
Myra filled notebooks with her feelings about Brady. She pasted in William Wordsworth’s poems and quotes about love and obsession. Ian, according to Myra, may have had little experience with intimacy. In 1961, he attempted to kiss her and bruised her with his teeth as he walked her home from the Christmas party.
They went to “The Nuremberg Trials,” a documentary, for their first date. Myra realized then that she would never be bored. Brady began giving her reading lists, which included works by Friedrich Nietzsche. He argued that religion stifled human potential, and subsequently, Myra stopped going to church after he told her that there was no God.
Bonding Over Pornography and Sadism
Ian and Myra’s first sexual experience together was, as Myra recalls it, violent and aggressive. During the act, Ian hit and bit her, leaving her bruised and battered. Journalist Duncan Staff, who later inherited her papers, said she entered this world partly because of her childhood. Her father’s beatings had prepared her for a man who treated her as an object.
As their relationship progressed, she would pose for explicit photos and listen to Brady describe rape and murder as “the supreme pleasure.” He portrayed killing children as the ultimate act of control and transcendence. Myra, intoxicated by forbidden ideas, appeared ready to follow him.
The Turning Point: Drugging and Rape
According to Myra’s own account, on one occasion, Brady escalated his sadistic fantasies further. He drugged her using her grandmother’s sleeping tablets, physically abused, sexually assaulted and then took illicit photos of her while she was unconscious. The combination of violence, humiliation, and documentation broke her remaining resistance.
From that point forward, she was no longer offended by actual atrocities. She later claimed she had entered a “different mental state,” but investigators and prosecutors saw only a willing accomplice. The transformation set the scene for the Moors Murders.
The Moors Murders: The Killing Spree
The first victim of the Moors Murders, 16-year-old Pauline Reade, disappeared on 12 July 1963. She was on her way to a dance, wearing new white stilettos her parents had bought for the occasion. Myra had already established a rapport with Pauline because Pauline was friends with Myra’s sister, Maureen. Myra approached Pauline and offered to drive her around Saddleworth Moor while claiming to be in need of assistance in finding misplaced gloves, persuading Pauline to get into the car.
Ian Brady secretly followed them on his motorbike. Brady took Pauline from the car and brutally abused her sexually and physically, beating and stabbing her. He inflicted such severe cuts to her throat that contemporary reports indicate he severed her spinal cord. Hindley later admitted to assisting in the burial of Pauline’s body. Decades later, when police finally found her remains, her new white stilettos were still with her and were later returned to the family.
Targeting John Kilbride
Just a few months after the previous disappearance, 12‑year‑old John Kilbride vanished from Ashton‑under‑Lyne. Hindley, who often bought stockings at the market where John earned pocket money helping stallholders, approached him there on 23 November 1963. She offered him a ride home, suggesting a detour and the same excuse given to Pauline, to look for Myra’s lost glove.
This time, she drove him to the moors with a deliberate plan: she had lined the boot with polythene and brought a serrated knife and a length of cord. Once there, Brady sexually assaulted John, attempted to cut his throat with the knife, and then used the cord to strangle him. The pair subsequently buried his body in a shallow grave on the moors, and John’s body was not seen again until 21 October 1965.
Luring Keith Bennett
On June 16th, 1964, the pattern was repeated. Keith Bennett was 12 years old when he walked approximately one mile from his home to his grandmother’s house. Because he made the trip frequently, his mother gave her approval. When Hindley arrived in her Mini, she asked him to assist with packing boxes. Agreeing, he got into the vehicle.
They drove to Saddleworth Moor and met Brady. According to Hindley, Brady took Keith to a gully near a stream. He raped and tortured the boy, then strangled him. Hindley claimed she waited in the car, but Brady said she helped. Keith’s body has never been found despite repeated searches.
The Murder of Lesley Ann Downey
Lesley Ann Downey was 10 years old when she left a Manchester fairground on December 26, 1964. She was enticed to 16 Wardle Brook Avenue by Hindley and Brady. In the bedroom, they stripped her, bound her, gagged her, and took pictures. Brady’s 13-minute video recording of her pleading for her life is the most damning evidence in the case.
Hindley can be heard telling her to “shut up” and speaking in a cold, detached tone. Brady later stated that Hindley helped strangle Lesley with a cord. When police found the tape in their suitcases at Manchester Central Station, they had enough proof to arrest her. The recording was played to a silent courtroom during their trial.
The Final Victim, Edward Evans
On October 6, 1965, 17-year-old Edward Evans responded to Brady’s job advertisement. He arrived at 16 Wardle Brook Avenue, where Myra’s 17-year-old brother-in-law, David Smith, was also staying. Smith drank minibar wine alongside them. Brady unexpectedly attacked Edwards with an axe, striking him 14 times before strangling him.
Hindley pretended as if nothing unusual had occurred. She made tea and joked about the “mess” while covering bloodstains with plastic sheets. Smith later told police that she treated horror as if it were chores.
Arrest, Investigation and the Role of David Smith
In October 1965, David Smith walked Myra home from her sister’s flat. She invited him to drink wine and hear Brady’s stories. He heard a long scream, then a voice shouting for help. When he entered the living room, Brady was holding a young man with an axe.
Brady hit Edward Evans repeatedly, then strangled him. Hindley cleaned up while Brady bragged about other victims buried on the moors. David helped out of fear, but he left the house devastated. He reported the killing to the police the next day.
The Arrest at 16 Wardle Brook Avenue
Police entered the house disguised as a bakery delivery team. Superintendent Bob Talbot knocked on the door and requested a key to the room containing the body. Hindley reluctantly gave it over. Officers discovered Edward Evans’ body wrapped in plastic alongside a bloodied axe.
Police immediately arrested Brady, while Hindley initially claimed she was horrified by a failed argument. She remained free for 4 more days, during which she threw away evidence at work. Detectives did not suspect her at first because no female‑led serial pedophile couple had ever been seen before.
The Suitcases and the Tape
Inside the house, investigators discovered a ticket hidden in Hindley’s communion book. It was linked to 2 suitcases at Manchester Central Station. Lesley Ann Downey’s nude photos and a recording of her final screams were in the suitcases. Hindley wept as police played the tape, but former detective Ian Fairley said she realized it was her death sentence.
She still denied killing Lesley, claiming she only sounded harsh because she feared the neighbors. Her refusal to admit the tape’s contents forced the victim’s mother to identify her daughter’s voice. The cruelty of that moment cemented public revulsion toward Hindley.
Trial, Conviction and Aftermath
The trial opened on 19 April 1966 at Chester Assizes. The case drew global attention. Both defendants pleaded not guilty. The prosecution relied on Smith’s testimony, Maureen’s evidence, and the tape of Lesley Downey. The jury heard the 13‑minute recording in full.
Hindley claimed Brady had bullied her into the abductions. She denied carrying out any murders. She said she waited in the car for Pauline Reade’s killing. The judge later said he could not see Brady as redeemable, but he thought Hindley might be different if removed from his influence.
Read More: Inside the Life of America’s Deadliest Woman
The Verdict and Sentencing
The court convicted Hindley of the murders of Lesley Ann Downey and Edward Evans on May 6, 1966. The court convicted her of harboring Brady after he murdered John Kilbride. They sentenced her to 2 life sentences concurrently. They spared her from execution because the death penalty had been abolished months prior. The court convicted Brady of 3 murders and sentenced him to 3 lifetime terms. Hindley’s image as a woman abducting and murdering children became a symbol of calculated evil, causing public outrage.
Confessions and the Release of Pauline Reade’s Body
In 1987, Hindley gave a full confession, admitting participation in all 5 murders. Hindley’s confessions revealed that they buried Pauline Reade and Keith Bennett on the moors. Authorities discovered Pauline’s body on 1 July 1987, still wearing her party dress. They have never conclusively found Keith’s grave. Keith Bennett’s mother, Winnie Johnson, campaigned for decades to locate her son. She died in 2012 without that closure. Her hostility toward Hindley persisted until the end. She stated she had no sympathy for her even in death.
Failed Parole, Death and Legacy
Hindley petitioned for parole in 1996. Michael Howard, the Home Secretary, refused, citing public outrage. She appealed the decision to the High Court and the House of Lords, but both dismissed her claim. She died in 2002 as a result of respiratory failure following a heart attack. In 2017, authorities transferred Brady to Ashworth Psychiatric Hospital, where he died after going on a hunger strike and facing forced feeding. This case significantly impacted British crime policy, forensic psychology, and public memory.
Read More: 60 Years Later, Coroner for Marilyn Monroe’s Autopsy Makes Stunning Allegation